Hi MJ ... take them both out and play with them and assess for yourself which ball that you prefer. Try hitting some shots into the green with the two and assess their performance characteristics. The same goes for shorter pitch shots and then lastly, your tee shots.

As a 5 handicap, you are hitting a pretty good number of Greens in Regulation so you also understand that the performance of the ball in the "scoring zone" is very important - vital really to scoring well. The rest all comes down to personal preference (ie: feel of the ball, when putting, etc.). I'll be interested in what you conclusion you arrived at. :-)