Never cared for a 52* wedge, never used a 58.

If you were to use PW + 1 other, 58 might be better than 60.

Tanner, 

One of the biggest factors in making sure you have the right wedge mix in your set, is making sure that the gapping is consistent.  You want to be sure that you can cover all yardages from your PW through to your sand/lob wedge.  This being said, there is no standard to what wedge lofts you use in your bag, just make sure you can cover gaps of 10-15 yards between each wedge.  This will help to eliminate having to rely on any shorter finessed shots.  If you, for example, hit your PW 130 yards (full) make sure you can hit your gap wedge (50*,52*, or 54*) 115 yards (full).  As you get down to your sand wedge/lob wedge, you will need to determine how good of a wedge player you are, because you may need to add another wedge higher lofted then the 58*/60* if you don't feel comfortable hitting the 1/2 shots from close distance (ie. 50-60 yards). 

Hope this helps!

Cameron

1-888-TITLEIST

I'll agree with Quintin on a 52. I tried some(a Harmonized Gap, Vokey 252-08 and a RAC 52) and didn't really find any added value in them. On the other hand, I've tended to like a 51 deg gap with a bit more bounce (probably because old school PW were 50 deg). I had a Golfsmith P2 that was my go-to club for 80-90 yard shots. I also had a V Foil 50 that was great out of long bunkers but I didn't use it for other short game shots. The Vokey Spin Milled c-c 50-08 is rather versatile (especially since I set the loft to 51 - great on long bunker shots). For me, the 54-11 (bent to 55) is also a very versatile club. I can get out of soft sand, do long bunker shots in hard sand and at least about 75% of my shots <50 yd.

I had a set of Golfsmith P2 irons in 2007 and used its PW (47), GW (51), a Vokey 258-12 and a couple different 64 deg wedges (Harmonized Trouble Wedge and Alien 64-05) for 2 years. The 58 was pretty much my short game but its only real short fall was longer bunker shots. For hard sand I used the 64.

My sand game was about average then but nowhere near like it is now. I got used to 47 and 55 as a PW-SW combo when I constructed my own irons in 2009 and used that until the beginning of this year (when I went to Eye 2 irons). My LW-XW combo for a year and a half was CG15 DSG 58 and 64 with a DIY 60-10; it was good but the limitations of the CG15s were tight lies so I replaced them and went to Vokey Spin Milled 60-07 and 64-07.

I briefly tried out a Spin Milled 58-12 cc this year, thinking it would do the same as my old 58 but I didn't like it so I returned it to the store. I'm pretty happy with my short game setup now. My 9 iron is 45 deg. I have 50-08 and 54-11 bent 1* weak (adds bounce) and 62-07 Spin-Milled cc.

It is pretty simple and no confusion on what to use. I have my distances pretty wired and have control down to an art. I primarily use my GW and SW within 60 yards and the 9 iron from 80-120.