Assuming you are right-handed, this matrix should help you. Have you got it setup as Standard A-1 at the moment? If so I would be tempted to shift it to B-2 and hit some balls with that setting.

I will try the B2 and C3 setting.
All of my clubs are fitted except the hybrid. Ist has a tensai blue shaft.

Definitely should investigate the shaft differences within your set. The weight and flex difference is probably the culprit, especially if it is the only one that was not fitted. Try to get the hybrid version of what you use in your fairway metals. Good luck.

It could be set up or just too outside to in on the downswing. I noticed this year my irons go longer but my wedges are giving me a real hard time and bc of that my swing continues to change with them to figure out a proper swing thought...you may have some of that going on as well. Golf is mental, sometimes I wish it wasn’t. Best of luck working it out!

Were you fitted for the club or did you buy it off the shelf?

Move it back in your set-up, similar to a 4 or 5 iron and see what happens.

Anything on the left of the diagram would be a good place to start as the face would be more closed.

I'm suffering from the opposite problem ‍♂️

If you don't solve the problem by going to D4 or C3, you may want to look to a professional instructor to see if there is a setup or swing error (out to in?) with the hybrid. If the shaft is too stiff it may not be allowing the head to close through impact. Lastly, the length may be contributing. Too many potential problems for any of us armchair analysts to correct.

Titleist metals with a possible exception of TS-1 are slightly open in base settings, increasing loft from A1 will increasingly close the face. Personally, I need to be fitted in the 18-22 degree range between fairways and hybrids for a head and shaft combination that works.

I think i fixed it. I shift it to D4, +1° and a little bit of a closed Face.